The Dreaded DSAR: How to Handle Employee Data Requests Without Panicking

Share this post

It usually starts with a seemingly innocent email from an employee: 

“I’d like to see everything that’s been written about me.” 

If you run a small business or handle HR, your stomach might drop. But what they are exercising is a flat-out legal right under the UK GDPR and Data Protection Act 2018 known as a Data Subject Access Request (DSAR), also called a Subject Access Request (SAR).

DSARs are weapon choice #1 when workplace disputes, grievances, or disciplinaries start brewing. While it might feel like a tactical personal attack, it’s just the law. Handling it professionally (and calmly) is the best way to protect your business.

What Exactly is a DSAR?

A DSAR allows any individual to demand a copy of all the personal data your business holds on them. In an HR context, this means they get access to:

  • Internal emails and WhatsApp/Slack/Teams messages mentioning them.
  • Performance reviews and 121 notes.
  • Disciplinary, payroll, and grievance records.
  • Even handwritten or informal notes stashed in a drawer.

Your Step-by-Step DSAR Response Checklist

When a request lands, you have exactly one calendar month to respond. Do not scramble, just follow these steps:

  • Verify Identity: If the request comes from a personal email or a third-party solicitor, ask for a passport or driving licence. Never leak data to the wrong person.
  • Clarify the Scope: If they ask for ‘everything ever’, you can ask them to narrow it down (i.e. “Are you looking for emails between X and Y regarding the January grievance?”). You still have to respond if they refuse, but it’s worth asking.
  • Go Data Hunting: Search email servers, your HR software (like BreatheHR), shared cloud drives, and internal chat platforms.
  • Redact Ruthlessly: You are sharing their data, not everyone else’s. You must obscure other people’s names and private info. (more on this further down)
  • Send Securely: Use encrypted files or tracked post.

The Golden Rule: Watch What You Write Internally

Many businesses get burned by DSARs because of how managers talk behind the scenes. Informal emails or spicy Teams messages will see the light of day if a DSAR is triggered.

To keep your business out of hot water, train your managers to write with care:

  • Stick to facts: Avoid emotional or speculative language.
  • Depersonalise when possible: Instead of writing, “John Smith failed to meet his deadline again because he’s sloppy,” write, “The report was not submitted by the agreed deadline.”
  • Use official channels: Keep sensitive performance discussions out of casual chat apps.

Redaction 101: Strikethroughs Won’t Save You

Redacting means blocking out information that the requester shouldn’t see (like legal advice or other employees’ names).

Warning: Highlighting text in black or using a font strikethrough in Microsoft Word is not redaction. Requesters can easily copy-paste or reverse this to see the hidden text. Use proper redaction software (like Adobe Acrobat Pro) and flatten the files before sending. Poor redaction is an instant ticket to an ICO data breach complaint.

The “Can I Just Delete It?” Myth

  • Before a DSAR arrives: If data was deleted via your routine data retention policy, fine. You don’t have to recreate it.
  • After a DSAR arrives: Do not touch the delete button. Destroying data after a request has been made to intentionally hide it can lead to severe legal trouble. Pause all automatic deletion processes immediately.

Fact vs. Fiction: 6 DSAR Myths Busted

The MythThe Reality
“It’s only a DSAR if they explicitly say DSAR”False. A verbal request or an informal email like “Can I see my files?” legally counts.
“We can ignore it if the employee is being difficult.”False. It is a statutory right, regardless of how rocky your relationship is.
“We can charge them a fee for the paperwork.”False. DSARs must be fulfilled completely free of charge.
“We have to hand over company legal advice.”False. Documents covered by legal professional privilege are exempt.
“We must respond by tomorrow.”False. You have a full calendar month (with a potential 2-month extension for hyper-complex cases).
“We should just dump all raw files on them.”False. Over-disclosing files without filtering them breaches other people’s privacy.

 

How We Keep You Compliant

Sifting through thousands of emails and running proper redactions is tedious, high-stakes work. One slip-up can land you in front of the ICO.

At Peas in a Pod Consulting, we take the panic out of the process. We can help you:

  1. Sift, review, and legally redact your documents.
  2. Draft bulletproof, compliant DSAR response letters.
  3. Train your management team on how to communicate professionally in writing to avoid future risks.

Whether you’ve just received a tricky data request or want to ensure your internal policies are safe, get in touch with us today. Let’s make sure your business is protected.

Previous
The Policies You Don’t Know You Need
Next
What Happens When Employees Disagree? A Leadership Test for National Inclusion Week